One Fed official may have saved market from another rout. Why John Williams’ remarks matter so much

Communication at the Federal Reserve, particularly at the highest levels, rarely happens by accident.

Messages that come out of the top echelon, particularly the chair, vice chair and the powerful New York Fed president, are measured carefully, calibrated between delivering clear ideas about policy without causing undue reaction in financial markets.

That’s why a speech Friday from the current New York Fed leader, John Williams, mattered so much to markets. With his position comes membership in the Fed’s leadership troika, a group that also includes Chair Jerome Powell and Vice Chair Philip Jefferson.

So when Williams gave a nod to the likelihood of a “further adjustment in the near term” for interest rates, investors took it as a message from on high that the leadership is inclined for at least another rate cut sometime soon, likely at the December meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee.

“There is some ambiguity in the phrase ‘near term’ – but its most obvious reading is at the next meeting,” Krishna Guha, head of global policy and central bank strategy at Evercore ISI, said in a client note.

“And while it is possible that Williams was offering a personal view, signals from the other members of the Fed leadership troika (vice-chairman, NY Fed president) on key live policy issues are almost always approved by the chair and it would be professional malpractice for him to deliver this signal without Powell’s sign-off,” he added.

Williams’ comments on rates come at an especially sensitive time for the Fed and financial markets.

The policymaking FOMC, normally a consensus-driven group sometimes maligned for lacking diversity of thought, has found itself suddenly divided.

On one side are officials who see policy as still holding back growth and open for adjustment, while the other is represented by those worrying about inflation who see solid economic growth with no need for further cuts, particularly in light of reductions already in the books from September and October.

While Williams provided little insight into the longer-term trajectory of rate expectations, at least in the short term it looks like senior Fed leadership backs a cut.

That’s particularly important to financial markets that have wobbled lately over fears of an artificial intelligence bubble, coupled with ongoing geopolitical concerns and uncertainty over Fed monetary policy.

Stocks rallied Friday, with futures turning around after Williams’ comments caused a market repricing toward the expectation of a rate cut in December. Ongoing concerns about AI tempered the rally, but traders continued to place bets on a December move, assigning a 73% chance of a reduction, according to the CME Group’s FedWatch.

Williams likely saved the market Friday from a potential selloff that appeared to be taking shape, with stocks outside of tech mostly firm and supporting the major averages on the prospects of lower rates. The major benchmarks were hit hard Thursday and investors feared another big slide was coming on Friday. Major averages vacillated through the morning but were at session highs heading into afternoon trading.

“Williams intervention came after several other Fed speakers indicated reservations about [December] but drew back from categorical statements, perhaps indicating they recognize the [December] struggle was turning into a crisis of governance at the Fed and see the need to give Powell space to make the call,” Guha said.

To be sure, other speakers weren’t as enthusiastic as Williams.

Regional Fed presidents Susan Collins of Boston and Lorie Logan of Dallas both voiced hesitation about further cuts. In a CNBC interview, Collins expressed concern about inflation. Logan was even more hawkish, saying she wasn’t even sure she would have voted for cuts the previous two cuts. Collins votes this year on the FOMC, while Logan gets to vote in 2026.